# The driven review

> How a Probe review is driven card by card — from scoping to answer and status — and why 'no more cards' doesn't mean 'done'.

_Source: E-Sharp (esharp.se) · Probe guide_


A Probe review isn't a button you press once. It is **driven card by card**: Probe splits the board into a coverage map of review cards (playbook cards), and you — through your AI — work through them one at a time until nothing is left open. Probe doesn't reason on its own; it hands out cards, gathers evidence and keeps the count.

## Why the review is driven by cards

Each card is a bounded question about one part of the design, with its own goal, its own material and its own acceptance criterion. That makes the review traceable: every conclusion can be tied to a card and its evidence, instead of a loose "this looks fine".

## Start and scope an analysis

You (or your assistant) start an analysis on a board. Probe creates a run, splits the work into cards, and hands back the first ones to work on. You can scope to a focus area or re-review everything.

## What a card holds

A card carries four things: **goal** (what is to be decided), **collection** (what material is needed — schematics, datasheets), **questions** to answer, and **acceptance** (what it takes for the card to count as done).

## Four answers per card

Each card resolves to exactly one of four outcomes — never an assumed pass:

- **Clean** — checked and without remark.
- **Finding** — something to fix, pinned at the design with evidence.
- **Abstained** — couldn't be decided; states explicitly what's missing.
- **Boundary** — lies outside what Probe owns (e.g. pure manufacturing geometry).

It abstains rather than guesses: a clean report means *reviewed*, not *assumed*.

## "No more cards" doesn't mean "done"

Read the status right. The run's percentage says how far the work has got; a node's **headline %** measures evidence over the *active* parts — the ones that can do harm — so a card stays shallow as long as it holds any unproven active part. You can't average your way to a green board by clearing the easy 90 percent. The list running out means the cards have been worked through, not that every active part is evidence-backed.

## Revise and re-review — without losing work

An answer can be revised, and a run can be re-scoped when the material changes, without losing what's already been worked out (see [boards and takes](/en/probe/support/boards-takes-and-the-design-line)). Decisions are also invalidated on their own when the material they rested on changes.

---

Next: [read and export the findings](/en/probe/support/read-and-export-findings).

*Probe is E-Sharp's design-review engine. Probe doesn't reason on its own — the AI in your own tool does the reasoning and you make the technical call.*
